Church of England warns future of Down's 'under question'


Ultrasound-guided amniocentesisImage copyright
Science Photo Library

The Church of England has warned the future existence of people with Down’s Syndrome is “under question”.

It has called for expectant mothers to be given “comprehensive, unbiased information” ahead of the NHS roll-out of Non-Invasive Prenatal Testing (NIPT) in England and Wales this year.

The blood test for high-risk women can offer an estimate of Down’s risk.

But the Church is concerned it could lead to more abortions on women carrying children with Down’s Syndrome.

The Church’s ruling General Synod will debate “valuing people with Down’s Syndrome” when it meets next month.

Down’s syndrome is a genetic condition that typically causes some level of learning disability and characteristic physical features.

NIPT involves taking a blood sample from the woman to look for DNA from the baby circulating in her blood.

The new test should cut the number of women who need riskier diagnostic tests in pregnancy that can cause a miscarriage.

But Rev Dr Brendan MCCarthy, the CoE’s national adviser on medical ethics, said there was “anecdotal” evidence that some women were told there was “bad news” if their unborn children were diagnosed with Down’s Syndrome – and immediately offered terminations.

Actress and screenwriter Sally Phillips, whose son Olly has Down’s, addressed this in the BBC documentary, A world without Down’s syndrome.

“The doctor said to us: ‘I’m sorry, I’m so sorry.’ The nurse on duty cried. I don’t think anyone said anything at all positive,” she said. “It wouldn’t have been any different if they’d told me my child wasn’t going to make it.”

Image caption

Sally Phillips and her son Olly

Dr McCarthy said information given to mothers should include advice on whether they want to undergo NIPT at all.

The NHS test is optional and women who find out their baby has Down’s will get support from health professionals to help make a decision on whether to continue their pregancy, NHS England says.

Church of England policy opposes abortion, though recognises that there can be circumstances in which a termination is “the lesser moral difficulty”.

“There is a problem that if women are not given up to date information with regard to Down’s syndrome, it is possible that it may seem the natural thing to do, the normal thing to do is to go along a pathway that would lead to increased terminations of pregnancy,” Dr McCarthy said.

The National Screening Committee has said while it is aware there may be an impact on abortion, the voluntary test was there to give women information and it was up to them what happened next.

NIPT is also offered by private clinics. The Church said these providers should be subject to increased regulation.

The Nuffield Council on Bioethics previously found some private clinics giving too little advice and support.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *